clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

5 Fantasy Islands for Sale in Florida to Dream About

New, 1 comment

Ballast Key via World Property Report

Due to the overflow of eyeballs absorbing East Sister Rock Island, we've decided to expand our island coverage here at Curbed because who doesn't want to daydream about owning his or her own private ocean-wrapped paradise? For today's edition of Curbed Comparisons we'll be island hunting across a variety of price ranges, but none topping $16 million.

The Florida islands are ordered from least to most expensive, ranging from $1.5 million to $15.8 million.


Jewfish Key

Our first option is on a budget and not technically an entire island. For $1.5 million you could own a 2,400-square-foot home on Jewfish Key off the coast of Sarasota. It comes with about 300 feet of private beachfront.


1030 North Island

From here on out, it's private island or bust. This particular oasis off the coast of Tampa stretches almost six acres and features an enormous resort-style pool. Water envelopes about 95 percent of it with road entry on one side. The price is $5.5 million.


Fanny Key

This two-acre island in Monroe County has the best name of the bunch in Fanny Key. Listed at $5.9 million, it offers a four-bedroom, two-bathroom home and guest residence.


Twichell Island

Located in Stuart, this $5.9 million property sits on a 2.5-acre private island.


Ballast Key

Our final island of the day is both the largest and most expensive, totaling 14 acres and listed at $15.8 million. Ballast Key is the southernmost inhabited island in the United States. The seller is known as Mr. Key West.

So which island would you choose?


Next time we go island shopping, we will be ramping up our fantasy budget.

· Island Coverage [Curbed Miami]
· Mr. Key West Selling Island [World Property Journal]